To help you find the best brown sugar storage to keep brown sugar soft, we have tried out a multitude of top containers, testing to ensure they featured tight-fitting lids, to keep the sugar from hardening, and that they were available in multiple size options to suit a wide variety of consumers. We also liked storage containers made from long-lasting and durable components and those that were dishwasher safe. These are some of the must-have kitchen products to have in your home.
The best brown sugar storage option we tried was the Prep Solutions by Progressive Brown Sugar Storage Container. This sturdily constructed brown sugar container contains a tight-sealing silicone lid and stainless steel hinges and is available in multiple size options, up to 3.8 quarts. We also loved the removable terra cotta disk which helps to keep soft brown sugar fresh for long periods of time. Keep reading to learn more about the Prep Solutions by Progressive Brown Sugar Storage Container and the rest of the items on this list.
Top 4 Best Brown Sugar Storage
#1 Prep Solutions by Progressive Brown Sugar Storage Container
Award: TOP PICK
WHY WE LIKE IT: Durably made brown sugar storage container with a tight-sealing silicone lid and stainless steel hinges, in addition to a removable terra cotta disk which helps maintain freshness.
[su_row]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#4DB227″ radius=”0″]
[su_list icon=”icon: check” icon_color=”#4DB227″]
- Built-in terra cotta disk for freshness
- Locking silicone lid and stainless steel hinges
- Multiple size options, up to 3.8 qt
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#B2B9C3″ radius=”0″][su_list icon=”icon: ban” icon_color=”#B2B9C3″]
- Dishwasher safe, but we advise low settings
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[/su_row]
The Prep Solutions by Progressive Brown Sugar Storage Container is a fantastic brown sugar keeper, thanks to durably made components, including a tight-sealing silicone lid and stainless steel hinges. We also loved the removable terra cotta disk, which you rinse with water and place underneath the lid, helping to keep the brown sugar soft similarly to bread or marshmallows. The multiple size options, maxing out at 3.8 quarts, are also great for a wide swath of consumers. While we’re talking about storage, you’ll also want to read our review of the best onion storages/savers.
Though this brown sugar storage container is dishwasher safe, we’d advise washing it on low heat on the bottom rack, and be advised that the removable terra cotta disk cannot be placed in the dishwasher. If you like brown sugar in your coffee, read our best single-serve coffeemaker review too.
#2 OXO Square Pop Brown Sugar Storage Container
Award: HONORABLE MENTION
WHY WE LIKE IT: Made from BPA free plastic components, with an airtight silicone lid featuring push button technology for a tighter seal, and featuring a stackable design that works flawlessly with other containers from the brand.
[su_row]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#4DB227″ radius=”0″]
[su_list icon=”icon: check” icon_color=”#4DB227″]
- Airtight seal, thanks to button push design
- BPA free plastic components
- Stackable design integrates with other OXO items
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#B2B9C3″ radius=”0″][su_list icon=”icon: ban” icon_color=”#B2B9C3″]
- Only one size available that is made specifically for brown sugar
- Only silicone lid is dishwasher safe
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[/su_row]
The OXO Square Pop Brown Sugar Storage Container creates an airtight seal thanks to the company’s proprietary “Pop” push button design and a high grade silicone lid. We also loved that the plastic components comprising the container itself are free from BPA and that the stackable design easily integrates with other OXO brand containers, allowing for some space saving in the cupboards.
Though the size of this brown sugar jar is perfect for one pound of product, that is the only size available that is specifically designed for brown sugar. With brown sugar easily on hand, take a look at the best automatic pot stirrer too. Also, only the silicone lid is dishwasher safe, as the rest of the components must be hand washed.
#3 Rubbermaid Airtight Brown Sugar Storage Container
Award: BEST DISHWASHER SAFE
WHY WE LIKE IT: Dishwasher safe design that is also freezer safe, free from harmful BPA plastics and features a modular design that can easily stack with other containers to save space.
[su_row]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#4DB227″ radius=”0″]
[su_list icon=”icon: check” icon_color=”#4DB227″]
- Freezer safe and compatible
- BPA free
- Modular design stacks with other containers
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#B2B9C3″ radius=”0″][su_list icon=”icon: ban” icon_color=”#B2B9C3″]
- 1 size only, though it is enough for 7.8 cups
- Airtight seal, but could use clay additive for freshness
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[/su_row]
The Rubbermaid Airtight Brown Sugar Storage Container is a fantastic brown sugar keeper, thanks to a dishwasher safe design that is also freezer safe, for long term storage of other ingredients, and free from harmful BPA plastics. We also loved the modular design, which makes it easy to stack the container on top of other Rubbermaid storage products, to save space.
Though this brown sugar storage container does offer an airtight seal, we found that it benefitted slightly with the addition of clay, bread or another softening agent, to ensure long-term freshness. Additionally, the brown sugar container is only available in one size, though it is enough for nearly eight cups of sugar. For your next baking project, you can’t forget the best reusable baking cups. You may also want to get the best bread slicer if you love making homemade bread.
#4 Enloy Brown Sugar Storage Container Set
Award: BEST MULTIPACK
WHY WE LIKE IT: Multipack that ships with 4 containers that can store 65 oz of ingredients, including brown sugar, with a hermetically sealed airtight design and high quality stainless steel components.
[su_row]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Pros” box_color=”#4DB227″ radius=”0″]
[su_list icon=”icon: check” icon_color=”#4DB227″]
- Hermetically sealed jars for freshness
- Stainless steel components
- BPA free
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[su_column size=”1/2″][su_box title=”Cons” box_color=”#B2B9C3″ radius=”0″][su_list icon=”icon: ban” icon_color=”#B2B9C3″]
- Design is not see thru
- We’d advise hand washing instead of using a machine
[/su_list][/su_box][/su_column]
[/su_row]
This Enloy Brown Sugar Storage Container Set is a fantastic multipack that ships with four stainless steel containers, totaling 65 ounces of storage, featuring hermetically sealed rubberized airtight lids that will keep brown sugar soft and fresh and keep insects out. We also loved that the silicone gaskets used for these containers are BPA free.
Though these are great for storing a variety of ingredients, in addition to brown sugar, the containers are not see-through, which could be an issue for some consumers. Also, though these are technically dishwasher safe, we’d advise hand washing, as the finish can dull after being placed in a dishwasher. If you’re looking for another great gift for somebody trying to complete their kitchen, try the best manual can opener.
How We Decided
To help narrow down to the above list, we primarily thought about how to keep sugar from hardening. In order to achieve that end, we needed to figure out why does brown sugar gets hard. The answer, in a word, is air. Air particles seep into the molasses in the sugar, causing particles to fuse together.
So, we looked for brown sugar storage solutions that were extraordinarily airtight, via a variety of methods, helping to keep air out of the container and, thus, keeping the brown sugar as soft and fresh as the day you purchased it. These airtight containers boast the added benefit of keeping out unwanted insects, mold, and other nasties you don’t want near your sugar.
After making sure the above storage containers offered airtight seals, we looked for additional features, such as the ability to be placed in the dishwasher, for easy cleaning, and the freezer, for the long-term storage of other ingredients. We also liked containers made from high-quality components, such as silicone, BPA free plastic, and stainless steel among others.
We also made sure to feature a wide variety of size options on the above list, with our smallest pick still being able to store up to one pound of brown sugar. Finally, we liked brown sugar storage containers with modular designs, allowing for easy stacking, thus saving some much-needed space in your cupboards.
See Also: You may also want to take a look at the best butcher block oil if you want to protect your cooking surface.
Best Brown Sugar Storage Buyer’s Guide
The Most Important Features to Consider
- Airtight Seal
The most important feature to look for when you are shopping for brown sugar storage containers is an airtight seal. This is important for several reasons. Primarily, airtight containers keep the brown sugar soft and fresh for long periods of time, as it is the air that causes brown sugar to harden. Additionally, hermetically sealed containers can keep out roaming insects, such as ants and larvae. These airtight seals are typically maintained via rubber seals and silicone lids. - Freshness Additives
In addition to a high functioning airtight seal, you may want to look into freshness additives of some sort. Clay can help keep brown sugar soft and fresh for a long time, as our top pick includes a removable terra cotta disk for just that purpose. Bread is also a good choice. Why does bread keep brown sugar soft? The bread ends up absorbing any errant moisture and air particles, keeping the brown sugar fresh and vibrant. - Cleaning
You want to make sure that your chosen brown sugar storage container is easy to clean. To that end, we included several models that could be placed in the dishwasher, for ease-of-use. Others require hand washing, but the procedure is often simple, requiring just a simple wipe down, as brown sugar doesn’t leave as much of a mess as some more liquid-based ingredients.
